Couple of days ago, Indian internet users woke up to something unexpected – A whole bunch of websites such as Vimeo, Dailymotion, Pastebin and popular websites that share torrent files were blocked from all major ISPs in India. Anyone who tried to access these sites directly was greeted with this simple error message:
This was similar to the censorship imposed in 2006, where the Government officials decided that a few websites weren’t of use to the general public and imposed a generic ban on domains that hosted them, to stop terrorism. The new censorship was confusing, since the categorization of websites blocked did not appear to seem something that could have come from the Government.
Upon a bit of digging, someone on Twitter came up with this link that identified one Chennai based company named CopyrightLabs with their CEO making a public statement as to the reason behind the ban. (At the time of writing this, the website remains ‘closed for maintenance’). Apparently, the company specializes in preventing movies from being pirated.
The company advertises themselves as someone who specializes in preventing movie piracy, something that threatens the movie industry. From what I can remember reading, they list file sharing servers (Rapidshare, Megaupload, …), video sharing services (Youtube, vimeo, dailymotion, …) and torrent sites as reason for piracy and loss of crores of rupees for Indian movie producers (!!). Do note that website never mentioned the use of a torrent client or the protocol itself, but just targeted torrent file distribution sites. The language used throughout the site was, at best, mediocre and was not proofread (To whomsoever wrote it – if you’re reading this – Sorry, I know that hurts, but that’s what it is!)
To anyone who’s spent enough time on the internet – the website speaks for itself – it does not come across as a technology company. Unfortunately, we are not whom they’re trying to market themselves to, and they seem to be doing a good job in that division – hit the nail right on the head. Instead of using technology, like what this company did recently, CopyrightLabs uses a more basic approach – they file a court case and order ISPs to block the mentioned websites (a copy of the court order is available in the link mentioned above).
There was a lot of hue and cry on twitter, to which the following responses were issued by the CEO of Copyright Labs and someone posting on behalf of Copyright Labs:
I’m not sure whether these statements about blocking individual links is true and I cannot verify, since the court order *does not* mention individual links, and it was issued well in advance. Perhaps if you have some information, you could help me out (I’m a curious person, I do not benefit in any way out of this).
Several tried to reach out to their ISPs, but the response from them was pretty much standard, that stated that the websites were blocked due to a court order. This article has some details of how to sue RTI to get that information, along with responses from an ISP.
The current state of affairs is a shame – looks like anyone can get a court order and block any website that they would like to. Shame on companies that do this, shame on those who use their services and shame on the court for encouraging such demands, instead of asking them to really invest time into developing the required technology.
Nevertheless, no one was impacted directly – if CopyrightLabs was into technology, they would have known that the ISPs methods to ‘block access’ wouldn’t be as effective as they though. Even the Great Firewall of China has not prevented people from accessing blocked websites. Oh well, they may have succeeded in blocking out the average user from accessing vimeo, or a torrent file sharing site, but then …
I can only chuckle at their ignorance, and hope they learn. And as someone rightly pointed out on Twitter (sorry, I can’t remember who it was) – the producers employing these methods don’t lose money to piracy, it’s just that they make bad movies and people don’t want to watch them.
















































